Submitted by Erik Hajek
Support engineer
Since the days of mammoth sized CRT monitors appear to be numbered, how in the world am I supposed to view stereo imagery?
Now that many companies are reporting that they are no longer producing CRT monitors, many GXP users are asking the same question. Fear not, my fellow stereo viewing geospatial types; all is not lost.
Over the past few months, I have had the opportunity to try out several different stereo display options in the hope of finding that one special monitor I call the “Holy Grail” of stereo monitors. This special monitor should have the following qualities:
- light weight
- flat panel
- high-resolution
- easy to set up and configure
- work well when roaming, or in mono mode
In addition, the monitor should not require a separate apparatus such as synch box, ZScreen or active glasses. Last but not least, I should not have to take out a second mortgage to pay for it.
You may be thinking to yourself that I should be committed for believing a monitor like the one described above could exist. You may be right; but I set out to prove that such a monitor was a reality and I’m happy to report…it sort of is.
The stereo displays I evaluated include: Planar, MacNaughton, MiraCube, and True3di. Ratings are based on ease of use, set up/configuration, display/performance and cost. Each stereo display is given a number based on the following rating system:
Holy Grail criteria
5 = best
1 = least desirable
Note: All prices are approximate; contact the manufacturer for exact pricing.
Stereo displays reviewed
Planar

Planar SD01710 17-inch LCD display
Model reviewed: Planar SD01710 17″ LCD Display
Other models available: 20″ SD2020, 24″ SD2420W, 26″ SD2620W
Price: Approximately $4,000 for model reviewed
Specifications and additional stereo display models can be found at:
http://www.planar3d.com/3d-products/
The Planar monitor uses two LCD flat panels with a semi-reflecting mirror at a diagonal between them. A special pair of polarized glasses is used to view in stereo. The Planar monitor requires a computer that contains dual PCI Express slots (if dual screen display is required) and the ability to hold a separate stereo flip card. The benefit is increased resolution for each monitor because each is run off an individual video card, provided by Planar. The display performance is also excellent; graphics appear clean and crisp. In addition, there does not seem to be any lag or other issues when roaming over imagery.
The Planar system can be more difficult to set up compared to some of the other options below, which is primarily due to the need for additional hardware. However, once properly configured and set up, the Planar monitor is easy to use, and the LCD displays are bright enough to allow stereo viewing even in a well lit environment.
RATING
Ease of use: 4
Setup/configuration: 2
Display/performance: 5
Cost: 2
Total score: 13
MacNaughton

McNaughton Perceiva 19-inch LCD display
Model reviewed: Perceiva DSD190 19″ LCD Display
Other models available: N/A
Price: Approximately $6,500 for model reviewed
Specifications for this display can be found at:
http://www.nuvision3d.com/download/Perceiva%20sheet-corp-mid.pdf
The Perceiva stereo display is an all-in-one unit containing a synch box and two LCD displays. However, the total size of the monitor is much smaller and lighter than a CRT monitor. The Perceiva has a flat screen which is very bright, making stereo viewing in lighted areas easy. A benefit of this monitor is the wide angle of view; you do not have to be directly in front of the monitor or at a certain height to see stereo. Additionally, set up is a breeze; only one stereo enabled video card is required, along with the choice of using one DVI or VGA input.
The monitor can cost more than some other options; however, there is no need for additional hardware. The light source within this monitor is very bright, which means it will get extremely hot. Imagery can look somewhat grainy in mono mode when compared to standard flat panels, but when in stereo mode, the monitor performs well. Lastly, when roaming around an image, it can appear to blur more when compared to roaming on a standard flat panel.
RATING
Ease of use: 5
Setup/configuration: 4
Display/performance: 3
Cost: 1
Total score: 13
MiraCube

MiraCube G240S 24-inch LCD Display
Model reviewed: G240S 24″ LCD Display
Other models available: 31″ G320S, 19″ C190X, 19″ C190S
Price: Approximately $4000 for model reviewed
Specifications can be found at:
http://www.miracube.net/product/
The MiraCube stereo display has a 24″ glossy screen and looks like a standard 24” flat panel monitor. One of the best features of this monitor is how easy set up and configuration is; simply plug the monitor in and make sure the video card has been stereo enabled.
There are four stereo input modes to choose from: sequential frame, interlaced, and two-sub-field formats (images displayed side-by-side or top-to-bottom). SOCET SET uses sequential frame-to-display stereo. The monitor resolution must be set to 1900X1200 to display stereo. No matter what the input stereo format is, the monitor will reformat the video output to be horizontally interlaced, dropping the resolution to 1900X600 when displaying stereo. The reduction in resolution is not very noticeable when viewing imagery. The view is similar to that of the MacNaughton Perceiva monitors, with a slight graininess.
The interlacing method has a profound effect on graphics. Thin lines, those only one pixel wide, tend to look more like dashed lines than solid lines. Making the graphics thick alleviates part of the problem. The interlacing can also affect the cursor display by occasionally dropping the horizontal parts of the cross hair. Despite these deficiencies, the monitor proves sufficient for simple feature extraction and terrain editing.
The monitor has a fairly small sweet spot (six-degrees viewing angle), making it suitable for a single analyst, however, two people would have a hard time seeing stereo. When you venture too far out of the sweet spot, the image appears in pseudo-stereo.
RATING
Ease of use: 2
Setup/configuration: 5
Display/performance: 2
Cost: 3
Total score: 12
True3Di

True3Di 19-inch display
Model reviewed: 19″ True3Di
Other models available: 40″, 24″ and 8″ versions
Price: Approximately $4,000 for model reviewed
Specifications can be found at:
http://www.true3di.com/content/products.htm
This stereo display is very similar to the Planar setup; it contains two LCD monitors with polarized glass set at a diagonal between them. These LCD displays are housed within a single case making the monitor about as large and heavy as a standard CRT. Moreover, if you wish to run a second monitor such as a standard flat panel, a second video card is required on the machine. There is no need for an additional flip card as that is done within the True3Di display.
Since this stereo display uses two independent LCD monitors, the resolution is very good and the display performance is excellent. Roaming around an image is smooth, and viewing stereo in a lighted room is easy. The display is slightly harder to set up due to problems with the documentation; however, we have been in contact with the manufacturer and they are working on improving this. Once set up and configured, the display is easy to use. The stereo image appears to be at the back of a tunnel due to the fact that both LCDs are inside a case. This tunnel-like effect may take some time getting used to; but it does not seem to have any influence on production.
RATING
Ease of use: 2
Setup/configuration: 2
Display/performance: 5
Cost: 3
Total score: 12
Conclusion
The stereo displays featured in this review may not fit perfectly into the description for “Holy Grail” of stereo monitors; however, depending on the work environment and the products produced, any one of these displays provides an excellent alternative to the near-extinct dinosaur, CRT-asaurus.
Stay tuned. When I find the Holy Grail I will spread the word.
Note: Some of these vendors will be exhibiting at our forthcoming User Conference. I invite you to come and try these stereo displays, and decide for yourself the best possible CRT replacement.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact us at socetgxp.support@baesystems.com.